If the problems with this band can be summed up in one singularity, it's the vocals. Look, I know punk doesn't have its Pavarottis, but there needs to be a limit on how off-key and guttural one could be and still be considered a singer.
Musically, these guys aren't horrendous, but they sometimes slip into emo. Get this if you wish, but avoid the down-tempo "X-Mas Time" at all costs.